answer-reviewer-questions

$npx mdskill add tobihagemann/turbo/answer-reviewer-questions

Answers reviewer questions by recalling implementation reasoning.

  • Solves the task of drafting answers to PR reviewer questions.
  • Depends on /recall-reasoning skill and question threads from context.
  • Uses recalled reasoning from transcripts or fallback from diff analysis.
  • Outputs plain text answers per thread for downstream reply drafting.

SKILL.md

.github/skills/answer-reviewer-questionsView on GitHub ↗
---
name: answer-reviewer-questions
description: "For each reviewer question on a PR, recall implementation reasoning and compose a raw answer. Use when the user asks to \"answer reviewer questions\", \"draft answers to PR questions\", or \"explain reviewer questions\"."
---

# Answer Reviewer Questions

For each reviewer question thread, recall the implementer's reasoning and compose a raw answer. The answers are plain text and feed into a downstream reply-drafting skill that applies voice rules and reply formatting.

## Step 1: Collect Question Threads

Use the question threads from conversation context. Each thread has: thread id, file path, line (use `originalLine` when `line` is null), the reviewer's original comment, and the reconciled intent from `/interpret-feedback`.

If no question threads were provided, report that there are no questions to answer and stop.

## Step 2: Answer Each Thread

For each thread:

1. Run the `/recall-reasoning` skill with `<path>:<line>`. It returns either recalled reasoning from a past transcript, or a fallback derived from reading the commit diff and surrounding code.
2. Compose a one-or-two-sentence answer from the returned reasoning. Quote or paraphrase the implementer's own words when the recalled reasoning explains the decision well.
3. Do not mention Claude, transcripts, or that the reasoning was recalled. The answer reads as the implementer's own explanation.

## Step 3: Output Answers

Output one block per thread:

```
**Thread <id>** (<path>:<line>)
<answer text>
_Grounding: derived from current code_
```

Include the `_Grounding:_` line only when `/recall-reasoning` returned no transcript. Omit it when the answer is grounded in recalled reasoning.

Then use the TaskList tool and proceed to any remaining task.

## Rules

- Do not load `/github-voice` or apply reply formatting. Downstream drafting applies voice rules when composing the actual reply.
- When `/recall-reasoning` returned no transcript, still compose an answer from the current code and include the `_Grounding:_` line so the downstream drafter knows the answer has weaker grounding.

More from tobihagemann/turbo

SkillDescription
apply-findingsApply findings by making the suggested code changes. Applies accepted verdicts, escalates ambiguous findings to the user, and offers to note genuine improvements for later. Use when the user asks to \"apply findings\", \"apply fixes\", \"apply suggestions\", \"apply accepted findings\", \"fix the findings\", or \"apply the review results\".
assess-technical-debtAssess project-wide structural technical debt: complexity hotspots, deprecated API usage, duplication clusters, and architecture rot. Ranks findings by impact and refactor effort into a report at .turbo/technical-debt.md. Use when the user asks to \"assess technical debt\", \"find technical debt\", \"review technical debt\", \"what should we refactor\", \"find refactoring candidates\", \"where is the code rot\", or \"what's our worst code\". Analysis-only — does not modify code.
changelog-rulesShared changelog conventions and formatting rules referenced by /create-changelog and /update-changelog. Not typically invoked directly.
claude-printRun a non-interactive Claude Code print-mode call from Codex. Use when the user asks to \"claude print\", \"ask claude\", \"run claude\", \"consult claude\", or when a Codex Turbo skill needs Claude as an independent peer reviewer.
code-styleEnforce mirror, reuse, and symmetry principles to keep new code consistent with surrounding code. Use when writing new code in an existing codebase, adding new features, refactoring, or making any code changes.
codex-execRun autonomous task execution using the codex CLI. Use when the user asks to \"codex exec\", \"run codex exec\", \"execute a task with codex\", or \"delegate to codex\".
commit-rulesShared commit message rules and technical constraints referenced by /stage-commit and /commit-staged. Not typically invoked directly.
commit-staged-pushCommit already-staged changes and push in one step. Use when the user asks to \"commit and push staged changes\", \"commit and push what's staged\", or \"commit staged and push\".
consult-claudeConsult Claude Code for second opinions, brainstorming, or difficult debugging from Codex. Use when the user asks to \"consult claude\", \"ask claude\", \"get claude's opinion\", \"brainstorm with claude\", or \"discuss with claude\".
consult-codexMulti-turn consultation with Codex CLI for second opinions, brainstorming, or collaborative problem-solving. Use when the user asks to \"consult codex\", \"ask codex\", \"get codex's opinion\", \"brainstorm with codex\", \"discuss with codex\", or \"chat with codex\".