rendering-strategies

Name: rendering-strategies
Author: kostja94/marketing-skills

$npx mdskill add kostja94/marketing-skills/rendering-strategies

Optimizes rendering strategies for SEO and crawler visibility

Identifies appropriate static vs dynamic rendering methods based on project needs.
Deploys tools like server-side generation (SSG) and server-side rendering (SSR) to ensure content is accessible.
Decides between SSG, SSR, ISR, CSR, and other techniques for optimal SEO performance.
Provides recommendations and solutions for crawler visibility issues such as JavaScript execution delays.

SKILL.md

.github/skills/rendering-strategiesView on GitHub ↗

---
name: rendering-strategies
description: When the user wants to choose or optimize rendering strategy for SEO. Also use when the user mentions "SSR," "SSG," "CSR," "ISR," "static rendering," "dynamic rendering," "server-side rendering," "client-side rendering," "JavaScript rendering," "pre-rendering," "prerender," "content in initial HTML," or "crawler visibility." For crawl issues, use site-crawlability.
metadata:
  version: 1.0.2
---

# SEO Technical: Rendering Strategies

Guides rendering strategy selection and optimization for search engine and AI crawler visibility. **Golden rule**: Page data and metadata must be available on page load without JavaScript execution for optimal SEO.

**When invoking**: On **first use**, if helpful, open with 1–2 sentences on what this skill covers and why it matters, then provide the main output. On **subsequent use** or when the user asks to skip, go directly to the main output.

## Scope (Technical SEO)

- **Static vs dynamic**: SSG, SSR, ISR, CSR; when to use each
- **Crawler behavior**: Googlebot renders JS (with delays); AI crawlers do not
- **Component-level**: Content in initial HTML; tabs, carousels, nav
- **Dynamic rendering**: Prerender for bots when full SSR/SSG is not feasible

## Rendering Methods

| Method | When HTML generated | SEO | Best for |
|--------|---------------------|-----|----------|
| **SSG** (Static Site Generation) | Build time | ✅ Best | Blog, docs, marketing pages; content rarely changes |
| **SSR** (Server-Side Rendering) | Request time | ✅ Good | News, product pages; dynamic, personalized content |
| **ISR** (Incremental Static Regeneration) | Build + revalidate | ✅ Good | Large sites; static with periodic updates |
| **CSR** (Client-Side Rendering) | Browser (after JS) | ❌ Poor | Dashboards, account pages; no SEO needed |
| **Dynamic rendering** | On-demand for bots | ✅ Fallback | SPAs; prerender for crawlers, SPA for users |

### SSG (Static Site Generation)

HTML generated at build time; same HTML for every request. **Best for SEO**: crawlers receive full HTML immediately; optimal performance.

- **Use when**: Blog, docs, marketing pages, content that doesn't change frequently
- **Framework**: Next.js `getStaticProps`, Astro, Gatsby

### SSR (Server-Side Rendering)

HTML generated on each request. **Good for SEO**: crawlers receive complete HTML; supports dynamic, personalized content.

- **Use when**: News, product pages, user-specific content
- **Tradeoff**: Higher server load; slower TTFB than SSG
- **Framework**: Next.js `getServerSideProps`, Remix

### ISR (Incremental Static Regeneration)

Static at build; pages can revalidate after a period. **Good for SEO**: combines static performance with freshness.

- **Use when**: Large sites (millions of pages); content updates periodically
- **Framework**: Next.js `revalidate` in `getStaticProps`

### CSR (Client-Side Rendering)

Server sends minimal HTML shell; content renders in browser after JS loads. **Not for SEO**: crawlers may see empty content; indexing delays or failures.

- **Use when**: Dashboards, account pages, internal tools—no search visibility needed
- **Avoid for**: Public content, marketing pages, blog

### Dynamic Rendering

Serve prerendered HTML to crawlers; serve SPA to users. **Fallback** when full SSR/SSG is not feasible (e.g. legacy SPA migration).

- **How**: Detect crawler user-agent; route to prerender service (e.g. Prerender.io) or headless render
- **When**: JavaScript-heavy sites; migration period; product/docs with CSR
- **Note**: Google permits this; prerendered content should match user experience

## Crawler Behavior

| Crawler | JavaScript | Content in initial HTML |
|---------|------------|-------------------------|
| **Googlebot** | Renders JS (Chrome); may have multi-day queue | Full weight; SSR/SSG preferred |
| **AI crawlers** (GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot) | Do **not** execute JS | **Required**—CSR content invisible |
| **Bingbot** | Renders JS | Same as Googlebot |

**AI crawlers**: ~28% of Googlebot's crawl volume. Critical content (articles, meta, nav) must be in initial HTML. See **site-crawlability** for AI crawler optimization; **generative-engine-optimization** for GEO.

## Component-Level: Content in Initial HTML

Google does **not** simulate user clicks (tabs, carousels, "Load more"). Content loaded via AJAX or on interaction is not discoverable.

| Component | Requirement | Implementation |
|------------|-------------|----------------|
| **Tabs / Accordion** | All tab content in DOM at load | Server-render; use `<details>`/`<summary>` or CSS show/hide |
| **Carousel** | All slides in initial HTML | Server-render; CSS/JS for show/hide only |
| **Hero** | Headline, CTA, LCP image in HTML | No JS-only rendering |
| **Navigation** | All nav links in first paint | No JS-injected menus for critical links |

**Recommendation**: Server-render (SSR/SSG) all critical content; use JS only for interaction (show/hide, animation). Content loaded on click = not indexed.

## Decision Guide

| Content type | Rendering | Reason |
|--------------|-----------|--------|
| Blog, docs, marketing | SSG or ISR | Best SEO; fast; static |
| Product, news, dynamic | SSR | Fresh content; crawler-ready |
| Dashboard, account | CSR | No SEO; auth required |
| Legacy SPA | Dynamic rendering | Bridge until SSR/SSG migration |

## Output Format

- **Current setup**: SSG, SSR, CSR, or hybrid
- **Recommendation**: By page type
- **Component checks**: Tabs, carousel, nav—content in initial HTML?
- **References**: [Next.js Rendering](https://nextjs.org/learn/seo/rendering-strategies), [Vercel SSR vs SSG](https://vercel.com/blog/nextjs-server-side-rendering-vs-static-generation)

## Related Skills

- **site-crawlability**: AI crawler optimization; SSR for critical content; URL management
- **generative-engine-optimization**: GEO; AI crawlers don't execute JS
- **core-web-vitals**: LCP; SSR/SSG for above-fold; client-side hurts LCP
- **mobile-friendly**: Mobile-first indexing; content parity
- **tab-accordion**: Content in DOM at load; server-render tabs
- **carousel**: Content in initial HTML; server-render slides
- **hero-generator**: Hero in initial HTML; avoid JS-only
- **navigation-menu-generator**: Nav in first paint; no JS-only menus

More from kostja94/marketing-skills

Skill	Description
404-page-generator	When the user wants to create, optimize, or audit 404 error pages. Also use when the user mentions "404 page," "404 error," "error page," "page not found," "broken link page," "404 design," "custom 404," "404 redirect," "404 page UX," or "404 recovery." For sitewide page planning, use website-structure.
about-page-generator	When the user wants to create, optimize, or audit About page content. Also use when the user mentions "about page," "about us," "company story," "our team," "about section," "company overview," "brand story," "team page," or "who we are." For sitewide page planning, use website-structure.
affiliate-marketing	When the user wants to plan, implement, or optimize affiliate marketing strategy. Also use when the user mentions "affiliate marketing," "affiliate program strategy," "CPS model," "affiliate recruitment," "commission structure," "affiliate partners," "affiliate network," "affiliate tracking," "affiliate commission," or "partner marketing." For affiliate page, use affiliate-page-generator.
affiliate-page-generator	When the user wants to create, optimize, or audit affiliate program page content. Also use when the user mentions "affiliate program," "affiliate page," "partner program," "referral program page," "affiliate landing," "partner landing," "commission page," or "affiliate signup." For affiliate program strategy, use affiliate-marketing.
ai-traffic-tracking	When the user wants to track AI search traffic in GA4 or GSC. Also use when the user mentions "AI traffic," "ChatGPT referral," "Perplexity traffic," "AI Overviews," "GA4 AI sources," "AI search analytics," "track AI referrals," "AI search traffic," "Claude traffic," or "how to track AI traffic." For AI SEO strategy, use generative-engine-optimization.
alternatives-page-generator	When the user wants to create, optimize, or audit alternatives or comparison content (page or blog article). Also use when the user mentions "alternatives page," "alternatives listicle," "X alternatives," "competitor comparison," "vs page," "compare page," "best alternatives to X," "switch from X," "competitor brand traffic," "brand keyword ads," or "intercept competitor search." For competitor research, use competitor-research.
api-page-generator	When the user wants to create, optimize, or audit the API introduction/overview page. Also use when the user mentions "API page," "API landing page," "/api page," "API overview," "developer landing," "API marketing," or "API for developers." Note: API documentation (endpoint reference) lives in docs; use docs-page-generator.
app-ads	When the user wants to run app install ads, user acquisition (UA), or promote mobile apps. Also use when the user mentions "app ads," "app install ads," "UA," "user acquisition," "Google App Campaigns," "Apple Search Ads," "ASA," "UAC," "App Store ads," "Play Store ads," "CPI," or "app promotion." For store listings, use distribution-channels.
article-content	When the user wants to write, generate, or create article body content—blog post body, long-form content, how-to guide, listicle. Also use when the user mentions "write article," "article content," "blog post content," "article body," "long-form content creation," "generate article," "article draft," "how-to guide content," "listicle content," "information gain," or "content density." For single post page structure, schema, and SEO metadata, use article-page-generator. For blog index/listing page, use blog-page-generator. For short ad, landing, or email copy, use copywriting.
backlink-analysis	When the user wants to analyze backlinks, audit link profile, or identify link issues. Also use when the user mentions "backlink analysis," "backlink audit," "referring domains," "toxic links," "link profile," or "disavow file." For acquisition, use link-building.